Better Angels
November 6, 2009
Send this news item to a Friend
Sign-up for Daily News Updates
November 6, 2009
Soon after news of the Ft. Hood shooting had reached the airwaves, the Council on American Islamic Relations released a statement saying, "We condemn this cowardly attack in the strongest terms possible." The name of the alleged assailant, Major Malik Nidal Hasan, had necessitated a quick response from the group because of the fear that Muslims as a whole would be assigned collective responsibility for the actions of one man whose religious affectations were, at that point, unknown. Some reporters began pontificating about the dangers of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, which was just as irresponsible.
But CAIR's fears were sadly confirmed quite quickly, as John Nichols wrote yesterday evening. Michelle Malkin, whose book In Defense of Internment advocated for the use of racial profiling against Arabs and Muslims, quickly recycled a 2003 column suggesting that there was something wrong with allowing Muslims to serve in the armed forces. "Political correctness is the handmaiden of terror," Malkin tweeted. Don't you see? If we had just listened to her, and treated those people as enemies to begin with, this would never have happened. There are thousands of Arab-Americans serving in the armed forces, and many have given their lives defending this country -- Malkin would have us see all of them as potential traitors.
This is not unusual. In every community, there are those who make it their role to assign collective responsibility of the group's miseries to outsiders. Shortly after the shootings at Virginia Tech -- the immediate aftermath of which was rife with the same sort of Islamophobia -- Pat Buchanan was shrieking about immigration because the shooter, Seung-Hui Cho, was a South Korean national.
Indeed, the attempt to assign collective responsibility to Muslims worldwide for the murderous actions of a few is sadly predictable. Doing so is the first step in rationalizing the unthinkable and justifying the unjustifiable. But where this sort of reaction is to be expected from the likes of Malkin and Buchanan, far more shocking was the exchange between Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchinson and FOX News anchor Shepard Smith. Upon discovering Hasan's name, Smith said "The name tells us a lot, does it not, Senator?" to which Hutchinson responded, "It does. It does, Shepard."
Click here to read the rest of the article
